Rebecca Surman, professor in the Department of Physics & Astronomy at the University of Notre Dame
Rebecca Surman

All the tangible, physical matter of the universe consists of different chemical elements, swirled or stacked or squashed together to form everything from atmospheric gases, to densest rock, to the complex bodies of living organisms. Elements make up everything else—but how were they themselves made?

“Exactly where and how it happens is still a mystery,” said Rebecca Surman, professor in the Department of Physics & Astronomy at the University of Notre Dame. “We have made lots of progress in the past 50 years, but it's still not a solved question.”

The bare-bones answer is that elements are a byproduct of stars—some churned out steadily by a burning star throughout its life, and others created in one great burst from an astrophysical event, such as when a dying star ultimately explodes. But when, where, and why does this happen, and what types and amounts of elements are produced? At Notre Dame, multiple research groups are tackling these truly elemental questions from different research angles that run the gamut from theoretical, to observational, to applied.

The resulting insights filter into countless aspects of the human experience, from learning about the fundamental structure of our world in high school chemistry, to making use of nuclear energy, to drinking a barium milkshake before a gastrointestinal X-ray.

Surman’s area of expertise is modeling element-forming events, like star collisions, to better grasp what happens during and afterward. Her research group focuses especially on the rarest, heaviest elements. “The Earth is just a little speck in the cosmic sea of hydrogen and helium,” said Surman. “Everything heavier than iron—it's much less abundant, like orders of magnitude less.”

These heavy elements—from gold and platinum, to uranium, thorium, and far more rare and unstable elements—are primarily formed by a process called rapid neutron-capture: Extra neutrons are forced into an existing atomic nucleus and subsequently transformed into protons through radioactive decay, creating a slew of heavier and heavier elements, all in just a tenth of a second.

The driving force behind this energy-intensive transmutation is usually a neutron star, itself the relict of a massive supernova. “A neutron star is an incredibly extreme astrophysical object. It has more than the mass of our sun condensed into a space about the size of Manhattan,” said Surman.

Sometimes two adjacent neutron stars pull each other into orbit and begin drawing closer and closer together—a death spiral with a cataclysmic end. Surman’s models reveal the aftermath.

“Say I'm looking at a piece of mass that's ejected from a neutron star merger,” said Surman. “I have the initial composition. I have some idea about its initial density and its velocity as it is ejected into space. And then I follow the temperature and density of the material and the nuclear reactions that occur.”

Extreme events like this leave behind a signature with characteristic features—like certain proportions of newly formed elements, or the distinct energies and intensities of emitted gamma rays. Modeling the different patterns left by different events enables other researchers to infer what has been happening in eons past, out there in space, and to figure out what to look for in the future.

Evan Kirby, associate professor in the department of physics and astronomy
Evan Kirby

Evan Kirby, associate professor in the department, is one such researcher. He too studies the aftermath of major astrophysical events—but where Surman uses differential equations to model the theoretical patterns of thousands of moving radioactive parts, Kirby and his group are learning about the origins of elements from observational data pulled straight from the night sky.

The most vital piece of equipment, it turns out, is not the telescope. “The telescope is just a big light bucket that collects the light from the stars,” said Kirby. Rather, it’s the spectrograph that does the heavy lifting—translating simple starlight into a catalog of elements. “A spectrograph disperses the light into the rainbow of colors. And different elements absorb light at different wavelengths, different colors. So we just measure the amount of light that's missing and translate that into how much of that element the star has.”

By gathering spectra of stars of different ages and in different locations, and armed with theoretical knowledge from models like Surman’s, Kirby can untangle the history of his collected starlight. “I can not only trace how elements are being pushed around through the galaxy, but I can infer what events were happening to make those elements,” said Kirby. “Was it a supernova? Was it the winds from massive stars? Was it an exotic type of supernova, not just an ordinary run-of-the-mill supernova? Was it the collision between two stars?”

A game-changer for Kirby’s work is the Subaru Prime Focus Spectrograph, newly operational after 15 years of international collaboration. Unlike older instruments, which gather data from only one star at a time, this supercharged spectrograph can collect light spectra from 2,400 stars at once. “The first run completely made obsolete all the data I have on a couple of galaxies, which was actually a great feeling,” said Kirby.

Examining long-ago events—recorded as light and transmitted mind-boggling distances through space and time—can reveal a lot about the matter of the universe. But it’s also possible to learn about the nature and origins of elements in real time, right here on Earth.

Associate Professor Maxime Brodeur, Department of Physics and Astronomy at Notre Dame
Maxime Brodeur

Associate Professor Maxime Brodeur and his research group are helping build the N=126 Factory, a multi-nucleon transfer reaction facility at the Argonne National Laboratory in Lemont, Illinois. There they will produce and measure isotopes of elements that, in nature, exist only fleetingly during an astrophysical event before decaying into other forms. “The ones actually involved in the process are very exotic. We cannot even hope to produce those directly,” said Brodeur. “What we do is produce the ones along the way, along the path as they decay back to stability.”

Brodeur sums up the complex procedure as “smashing” a neutron-rich projectile onto a neutron-rich target to form these otherwise elusive isotopes. “Some of these are of critical importance for the rapid neutron-capture process,” he said.

At the N=126 Factory, these isotopes will be manually produced and characterized for the first time—ultimately yielding an extremely precise measurement of their mass, which is essential to understanding the network of nuclear reactions that takes place during an element-forming event among the stars.

This is where the trifecta of theory, observation, and hands-on application comes full circle. As experimental nuclear physicists like Brodeur gather more precise data about the nature of certain elements and their isotopes, Surman and her fellow theoretical astrophysicists are able to hone their calculations and models to greater accuracy, enabling observational astronomists like Kirby to better understand and describe space’s naturally-occurring phenomena.

“These are basically all of the ingredients you need,” said Brodeur.


About the author: After a decade in ecology research, Alice McBride earned a graduate degree in science writing from MIT and now works as a freelance science writer and academic editor.